Immich vs Nextcloud Memories

Both are self-hosted photo galleries projects. This page compares how well each one is actually maintained — the part you cannot see from a feature list.

Immich scores 93 against Nextcloud Memories's 85, putting it slightly ahead on the strength of a larger community. That measures project health, not feature fit — Nextcloud Memories may still be the right choice if it does what you need.
ImmichNextcloud Memories
Health score 93/100 85/100
Commits (11 mo) 2693 1355
Commits (last 3 mo) 756 1176
Stars 120k 3.9k
Latest release 18 Nov 2026 13 Nov 2026
Licence AGPL-3.0 AGPL-3.0
Built with Docker PHP
Typical RAM 2 GB 1 GB

Immich

Photo and video backup solution directly from your mobile phone (alternative to Google Photos).

93/100
Thriving

High commit volume, frequent releases and growing activity.

Maintenance 36/40
Releases 25/25
Community 20/20
Momentum 12/15

Commit activity more than 90% of tracked projects; popularity in the top 1%. How this is calculated.

Commits, last 11 months

2025-12: 131 commits 2026-01: 265 commits 2026-02: 300 commits 2026-03: 258 commits 2026-04: 236 commits 2026-05: 215 commits 2026-06: 270 commits 2026-07: 262 commits 2026-08: 252 commits 2026-09: 217 commits 2026-10: 287 commits

Nextcloud Memories

Fast, modern and advanced photo management suite. Runs as a Nextcloud app.

85/100
Thriving

High commit volume, frequent releases and growing activity.

Maintenance 32/40
Releases 25/25
Community 12/20
Momentum 15/15

Commit activity more than 81% of tracked projects; popularity more than 61%. How this is calculated.

Commits, last 11 months

2025-12: 5 commits 2026-01: 51 commits 2026-02: 10 commits 2026-03: 13 commits 2026-04: 27 commits 2026-05: 10 commits 2026-06: 23 commits 2026-07: 40 commits 2026-08: 93 commits 2026-09: 634 commits 2026-10: 449 commits

How to read this

Everything above is measured, not opinion: commit counts and release dates come from the public repositories, and the health score ranks each project against all 1362 projects we track. Read the full method.

What this comparison deliberately does not do is tell you which has the better feature set. Maintenance health tells you which project will still be receiving security fixes in two years. Decide that first, then compare features on the projects that survive the filter.

See every option in this category: self-hosted photo galleries.